CRS - Mullin v. Doe: Supreme Court Allows Termination of Temporary Protected Status for Haiti and Syria
- On June 25, 2026 the Supreme Court held 6 to 3 that the TPS judicial review bar applies to all non-constitutional claims.
- The Court held that the equal protection challenge to Haiti's TPS termination was unlikely to succeed.
- DHS may proceed with the terminations for Haiti (announced November 28, 2025, effective February 3, 2026) and Syria that district courts had stayed.
- The ruling appears to make most DHS decisions on TPS designation, extension or termination unreviewable.
- H.R. 1689, passed by the House on April 16, 2026, would require a Haiti TPS designation until three months after January 20, 2029.
This Legal Sidebar by CRS legislative attorney Hillel R. Smith, updated July 10, 2026, reviews the Supreme Court's June 25, 2026 decision in Mullin v. Doe. Under 8 U.S.C. § 1254a, the Secretary of Homeland Security (DHS) may designate a country for Temporary Protected Status because of natural disaster, armed conflict or other extraordinary and temporary conditions, and the statute states that there is no judicial review of the Secretary's determination on designation, termination or extension. DHS designated Haiti in 2010 after the earthquake, terminated the designation in 2018, and designated it again in 2021 and 2023. Secretary Noem announced the termination of Syria's designation on September 22, 2025 (effective September 30, 2025) and of Haiti's on November 28, 2025 (effective February 3, 2026).
Haitian and Syrian TPS recipients sued, in Miot v. Trump (D.D.C.) and Doe v. Noem (S.D.N.Y.). The district courts postponed the terminations, finding that the Secretary likely failed to consult appropriate agencies and, in Miot, that the Haiti termination likely violated equal protection. The D.C. Circuit denied a stay by 2 to 1 on March 6, 2026. The Supreme Court took both cases on March 16, heard argument on April 29, and on June 25 reversed by 6 to 3. Justice Alito's majority held that the judicial review bar covers the decision and the process leading to it, so it bars all non-constitutional claims, and that the Miot equal protection claim would likely fail because the cited statements were not overtly racial. Justice Thomas concurred, and Justice Kagan, joined by Justices Sotomayor and Jackson, dissented.
The sidebar says the ruling lets DHS proceed with the terminations and appears to make most TPS decisions unreviewable. It notes that Congress could amend the statute and lists pending bills, including H.R. 1689, which passed the House on April 16, 2026 and would require a Haiti designation until three months after January 20, 2029.
How to cite
Congressional Research Service (CRS), 2026, CRS - Mullin v. Doe: Supreme Court Allows Termination of Temporary Protected Status for Haiti and Syria, https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/LSB11446.html
- Rights holder
- Congressional Research Service (CRS)