Haiti Needs a Political Dialogue Alongside the Multinational Security Mission

Home ▶ Publications Haiti Needs a Political Dialogue Alongside the Multinational Security Mission While the U.N.-approved mission will help stifle gang violence, Haiti’s humanitarian crisis requires a full governance reset. Thursday, October 5, 2023 / BY: Keith Mines PUBLICATION TYPE: Analysis This week, the U.N. Security Council voted to send a multinational armed force to Haiti in the hopes of addressing the beleaguered Caribbean nation’s rampant gang violence and instability. While there is not yet an official timeline for its deployment, the Kenyan-led force will face a complex security environment — one that has been made all the more daunting by Haiti’s ongoing political turmoil. Whether the mission succeeds will hinge not only on the deployed force’s ability to quickly establish peace, but whether or not it can pave the way toward a meaningful and democratic government reset in the historically tumultuous country. Lire en français Search Share This Print the Page Bus passengers go through a police checkpoint in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, near the entrance of an area in Haiti’s capital controlled by the 400 Mawozo gang. October 20, 2021. (Adriana Zehbrauskas/The New York Times) USIP’s Keith Mines explains the U.N. decision to authorize the mission, the challenges it will face once on the ground in Haiti, and how the United States can facilitate a simultaneous political dialogue to give Haiti a chance to reestablish secure and stable governance. In October 2022, the Haitian government sent a letter to the U.N. secretary-general requesting a specialized armed force be deployed to stop the country’s ongoing humanitarian crisis caused by criminal gangs and their sponsors. The Haitian government envisioned this force would establish a safe environment that would Why did the U.N. authorize this mission and what will it do? allow hospitals and schools to function, food and water to be distributed, and reopen the free movement of people and the resumption of commerce. In the year since this letter was sent, the situation in Haiti has deteriorated further. In July 2023, a U.N. secretary-general report cited 2,094 homicides on the year — an increase of 67 percent from 2022. Meanwhile, half the country’s population remained food insecure and 200,000 people were internally displaced. Haitians born in the Duvalier period (1957-1986) have told me this is the worst they have ever seen the country, with gangs controlling as much as 90 percent of the capital Port au Prince and the police ineffectual in stopping their violent predations. Earlier this week, the U.N. Security Council passed a resolution on Haiti put forward by the United States and Ecuador by a vote of 13-0, with Russia and China abstaining. The resolution clears the way for Kenya to lead an international force that would deploy to Haiti and work with the Haitian National Police to confront the gangs and protect critical infrastructure.    Several other countries — the Bahamas, Jamaica, Italy, Spain, Mongolia, Senegal, Rwanda, Belize, Suriname, Guatemala, Antigua and Barbuda, and Peru — have also announced pledges of support. The United States has offered $100 million in financial support for the force and another $100 million to enable intelligence, equipment and logistics operations. In August, a Kenyan scoping mission went to Haiti to review the mission’s requirements. Kenya will send a contingent of 1,000 from its border police, which has extensive experience in peacekeeping operations, and will provide leadership of the overall mission. What are the challenges facing the mission? Kenya has expressed not only a willingness to lead the force but a firm determination to make the mission succeed. Such coalitions have been successful in the past, notably in East Timor from 1999-2000, when Australia led a multinational U.N.- mandated (but non-U.N. force) to address the humanitarian crisis and provide security until a U.N. force could arrive. Other U.N.-mandated international security missions conducted outside the conventional U.N. peacekeeping apparatus were led by the United States and NATO, including two previous missions in Haiti. Still, this latest Kenyan-led force will face a number of challenges in establishing itself in Haiti. First, there will be resistance by some Haitians to having yet another international security force in their country — especially given the legacy of past forces, which in one case unleashed a cholera epidemic that killed 10,000 and in another case was involved in sexual predation.  Second, past forces came to Haiti with immense size and strength — the 1994 force included 20,000 personnel and the 2004 force was made up of 6,400 soldiers and roughly 1,700 police officers. Featuring military components, fully enabled air support, mobility and quick-reaction elements, these missions created an intimidating presence to back up local Haitian police. As a result, violent resistance was minimal and ex-military, gangs and other violent actors were often quick to lay down their arms. This new force will be smaller and, as planned, will not include military components. Meanwhile, they will be confronting gangs that are better armed and potentially more resistant than in the past. Third, this new force will not have a natural connection to the communities it will be working in. Kenya has extensive experience in these kinds of gray-area operations and their personnel will be a quick study on what is required to succeed. But there will still be language barriers, culture clashes and the inevitable civilian casualties that will require constant engagement to overcome. The force’s ability to quickly establish dialogues with civil society on security issues will be important. They will also need to establish connections with gangs that may be willing to disarm and allow for a peaceful way forward, as opposed to gangs who will need to be engaged by force.  But the most significant challenge, and the true center of gravity for success or failure, is the political environment inside Haiti. Many fear that in the current environment, the force will simply be propping up an unelected and unpopular government that will not provide the support needed to build a new police force and match the efforts of the international force with effective governance. As Haitian civil society leader Pierre Esperance said in a recent op-ed: “Another international force in Haiti will never work without a functional government in place.” Alongside deploying a security force, the international community will also need to engage in a political effort. In addition to offering full financial and enabling support for the multinational effort, the United States will be the key player in any effort to reset the transitional government in Haiti. To many, U.S. support for the current government is the only reason it can hold on to power.  There are many challenges involved in a government reset, but there are also a number of good proposals on the table for how it might be done. To date, efforts have been technically sound and have drawn in a host of different players, including the ongoing effort by the Caribbean Community’s Eminence Group. But they have all What role can the United States play? fallen short thus far, as none have the leverage needed to coerce all parties to make the concessions required to develop an effective governing body. Some analysts and Haitian civil society leaders are calling for an arrangement similar to the Council of Sages, which was used in 2004 after then-President Jean-Bertrand Aristide gave up power. In that case, Haitian stakeholders selected five prominent individuals to form an executive body, from which they selected one member as the acting president. Other institutions were then formed in temporary fashion to flesh out the rest of the government and carry on with basic governance until elections were held two years later.   Getting to this kind of arrangement today would best be done by convening a national reconciliation conference. There are roughly a dozen key political movements that would need to be present, as well as civil society, the business community, religious actors and the current government. Given the already extensive work of the Montana Accord to build a broad-based coalition, they would be a key representative element for such a convening. Seats at the table would likely range between 20 and 30, with another 30 or so at a second table or participating in consultations.  While such a convening could be held in a Caribbean country, many argue that for the sake of symbolism it would be best to hold it in Haiti’s relatively safe northern region, perhaps Cap Haitian with its rich history and status in the country’s struggle for independence. Tickets to the gathering would need to be one-way. It should be conducted in an open-ended structure with the idea it would not end until there was an agreement (at which point, of course, there would be a return ticket). Outliers and non-participants would be able to join during the proceedings, with international and Haitian champions being allowed time to provide incentives for all to join and for full concurrence on conclusions. All options for government formation would need to be on the table, and all actors would need to be willing to step aside to accede to the will of the participants.    While many other countries would need to help at this point, especially Haiti’s friends in the Caribbean and the Americas, only the United States would be in a position to provide the critical inducements to ensure all key parties were willing to abide by the conference’s decisions. But it would need to do so well in the background.  If a newly formed transitional government could take office before the end of the year, it would be in a position to support the incoming force in the long work of resetting security, and together could succeed in giving Haiti a new chance at security and stability.    ABOUT THE AUTHOR Keith Mines Vice President, Latin America ISSUE AREAS Democracy & Governance Global Policy COUNTRIES Haiti USIP has a variety of newsletters and announcements with the latest analysis, publications and events. STAY INFORMED Sign up! How the World Can Better Support Women Peacebuilders Monday, May 20, 2024 By: Pétronille Vaweka;  Dr. Marie-Marcelle Deschamps;  Abir Haj Ibrahim;  Hamisa Zaja Whether it’s providing clean drinking water to displaced persons, organizing education for at-risk youth or directly engaging in mediation between warring parties, the 2023 Women Building Peace Award finalists have all shown themselves to be impactful advocates of peace and stability in their communities. USIP spoke to award recipient Pétronille Vaweka of the Democratic Republic of RELATED PUBLICATIONS Congo and finalists Dr. Marie-Marcelle De of Syria and Hamisa Zaja of Kenya about international community can help to emp of women peacebuilders around the wor Type: Blog Ce dont Haïti a besoin de la part des États-Unis et de la communauté internationale Wednesday, May 1, 2024 By: Georges Fauriol Malgré les distractions évidentes provenant des crises dans d'autres coins du monde, le désastre qui s'aggrave en Haïti attire tardivement une attention internationale plus large. Les critiques de la politique américaine envers Haïti émergent de tous les coins du spectre politique, et il y a beaucoup à critiquer, notamment si l'on étend la période à l'expérience politique d'Haïti depuis la fin des dictatures Duvalier dans les années 1980. Mais ici et maintenant, ces évaluations minimisent les chances déjà minces des efforts de médiation gérés par la Communauté des Caraïbes (CARICOM), à partir desquels a émergé le Conseil Gender;  Peace Processes présidentiel d'Haïti, une structure de gou Type: Analysis What Haiti Needs from the U.S. and International Community Wednesday, May 1, 2024 By: Georges Fauriol Despite obvious distractions from crises in other corners of the world, Haiti’s deepening disaster is belatedly drawing wider international attention. Critics of U.S. policy toward Haiti are emerging from all corners of the political spectrum — and there is much to be critical of, particularly if the timeframe is stretched to cover Haiti's political experience since the late 1980s and the transition from the Duvalier dictatorships. But in the here and now, these assessments short charge the admittedly tough odds of the most recent Caribbean Community- (CARICOM) managed mediation efforts from which has emerged Haiti’s Presidential Council, a transitional governance structure for the country. Democracy & Governance;  Global Policy Type: Analysis Ce qu'un gouvernement de transition en Haïti aura besoin pour réussir Thursday, March 28, 2024 By: Nicolás Devia-Valbuena;  Keith Mines Après des semaines de consultations, et au milieu d'une quasi-rupture totale de l'ordre et de la loi en Haïti, un effort dirigé par la Communauté caribéenne (CARICOM) pour créer un nouveau conseil de gouvernance de transition pourrait être sur le point d'être achevé. La mise en place du conseil permettrait l'entrée d'une force de sécurité multinationale qui pourrait ensuite se joindre à la police nationale haïtienne pour rétablir l'ordre. Certains ont suggéré l'inclusion de "facilitateurs" pour la nouvelle force de sécurité - soutien aérien, drones, renseignement. Mais pour gagner la confiance du peuple haïtien, le nouveau conseil de gouvernance aura besoin de ses propres "facilitateurs" populaires, d'un moyen systématique d'inclure de nombreux autres secteurs de la société Democracy & Governance;  Global Policy haïtienne qui sont actuellement ignorés o gouvernance. Type: Analysis Global Policy View All Publications In Myanmar war, crucial window looms for junta and rebels - Reuters Tuesday, May 7, 2024 Secure at Home, Putin Builds on the Alliances He Needs to Prevail in Ukraine - WSJ Tuesday, May 7, 2024 NATO and Indo-Pacific Partners - The Diplomat Monday, May 6, 2024 China in middle of India-Pakistan naval arms race - Asia Times Friday, May 3, 2024 LATEST NEWS 2301 Constitution Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20037 Tel: +1.202.457.1700 Experts Regions Issue Areas Education & Training Events Legal and Privacy Information | FOIA InquiriesThe United States Institute of Peace View All News About Publications Projects Grants & Fellowships Visit Connect Press Blog