Report on the criminal assizes of the 2007-2008 judicial year
- At least 393 cases were heard during the 2007-2008 assizes, 144 with a jury and 249 without.
- Of 676 persons tried, 374 were convicted, 166 were released and 136 were sent back to prison without being tried.
- Many defendants appeared after years of pretrial detention with empty files, and prosecutors had to drop charges in several cases.
- Witnesses cited by the prosecution, including police officers, often failed to appear, which led to cases being postponed.
- Some jurors were illiterate or under the legal age of 25, and some were accused of accepting money for favorable verdicts.
- The RNDDH calls the assizes a quantitative success whose quality needs improvement.
The Réseau National de Défense des Droits Humains reviews the criminal assizes held in 18 jurisdictions between October 2007 and September 2008, in the context of prolonged pretrial detention. It gives a count of cases heard, persons tried, convicted and released, with a table by jurisdiction. It recounts four symbolic cases tried in Port-au-Prince: the kidnapping and murder of a child, the killing of a television presenter, the sexual assault of a young woman by a police officer and another man, and the murder of a CIMO officer. The report then lists weaknesses in the organization of trials: weak judicial investigations, witnesses who fail to appear, absent defendants, jurors who are underage, illiterate or allegedly bribed, late appointment of defense lawyers, absent civil parties, and absent court bailiffs and clerks.
It also describes disruptions in Saint-Marc and Gonaïves, the latter after tropical storms Hanna and Ike. It concludes that the assizes succeeded quantitatively but need better quality, and recommends resources for investigating judges, witness attendance, careful juror selection and better defense.
How to cite
National Human Rights Defense Network (RNDDH), Report on the criminal assizes of the 2007-2008 judicial year, https://web.rnddh.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/Rapport-Assises-2008.pdf
- Rights holder
- Réseau National de Défense des Droits Humains (RNDDH)