Using the Organization of American States to End the Abuse of Restaveks
- The article states that an estimated 150,000 to 500,000 children work as restaveks, and other sources put the number at 300,000.
- It states that the 2003 Act prohibits restavek placement but sets no penalties and leaves the minimum age for domestic workers unclear.
- It states that as of 2014 the IBESR employed 150 people across Haiti, including 48 protection agents and 20 social workers, and the Brigade for the Protection of Minors employed 80 agents.
- It argues that the restavek system meets each element of forced labor under ILO Convention 29 and of child slavery under ILO Convention 182.
- It states that Haiti ratified the American Convention on September 14, 1977 and recognized the jurisdiction of the Inter-American Court on March 3, 1998.
- It proposes that the Court order Haiti to amend the 2003 Act, fund child protection agencies and publicize its child protection laws.
The article describes the restavek system, in which Haitian children are placed with host families and work without pay, and traces it to Haiti's slave history, poverty and cultural attitudes. It states that Haitian law, including the 1987 Constitution, the Labor Code, the 2003 Act and the Penal Code, prohibits the practice in theory but is weakly enforced because of limited funding, corruption and a dysfunctional judiciary. It finds that NGO efforts, the ILO and the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child cannot compel compliance or offer individual complaint mechanisms.
It argues that the restavek system violates Articles 6 and 19 of the American Convention on Human Rights and that a petition could go through the Inter-American Commission to the Inter-American Court, whose jurisdiction Haiti accepted in 1998. The author proposes a list of orders for the Court, including amending the 2003 Act, funding child protection agencies and publicizing the law. She also proposes a temporary program modeled on Liberia's GEMAP, with international experts in MAST and the IBESR.
How to cite
Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 2016, Using the Organization of American States to End the Abuse of Restaveks, accessed via HaitiDocs, https://www.haitidocs.org/doc/breyer-2016-using-oas-end-abuse-restaveks
- Rights holder
- Columbia Human Rights Law Review