(2010-04) MINUSTAH - Rapport du Secrétaire général sur la Mission des Nations Unies pour la stabilisation en Haïti (S/2010/200)
Resume — Rapport du Secrétaire général sur la Mission des Nations Unies pour la stabilisation en Haïti (MINUSTAH), soumis au Conseil de sécurité des Nations Unies sous la cote S/2010/200 en avril 2010. Il rend compte de l'évolution de la situation en Haïti au cours de la période considérée : situation politique et sécuritaire, droits de l'homme, situation humanitaire et progrès dans la mise en œuvre du mandat de la mission.
Constats Cles
- Rapport du Secrétaire général sur la Mission des Nations Unies pour la stabilisation en Haïti (MINUSTAH), cote S/2010/200, avril 2010.
- Couvre la situation politique, sécuritaire, des droits de l'homme et humanitaire en Haïti sur la période.
- Évalue la mise en œuvre du mandat de la mission et formule des recommandations au Conseil de sécurité.
- S'inscrit dans la série continue des rapports du Secrétaire général sur Haïti (MINUSTAH, MINUJUSTH, BINUH).
Description Complete
Ce rapport du Secrétaire général des Nations Unies sur la Mission des Nations Unies pour la stabilisation en Haïti (MINUSTAH) a été soumis au Conseil de sécurité sous la cote S/2010/200 (avril 2010). En tant qu'édition du rapport périodique du Secrétaire général sur la présence des Nations Unies en Haïti, il expose l'évolution de la période considérée : processus politique et gouvernance, environnement sécuritaire, état de droit et droits de l'homme, situation humanitaire, ainsi qu'une appréciation de la mise en œuvre du mandat de la mission et des recommandations au Conseil de sécurité. Il s'inscrit dans la série continue des rapports du Secrétaire général sur Haïti couvrant les mandats de la MINUSTAH, de la MINUJUSTH et du BINUH. Les chiffres et constats précis devraient être cités directement dans le rapport.
Texte Integral du Document
Texte extrait du document original pour l'indexation.
S/2010/200
United Nations
Security Council
Distr.: General
22 February 2010
Original: English
Report of the Secretary-General on the United Nations
Stabilization Mission in Haiti
I. Introduction
1.
By its resolution 1892 (2009), the Security Council extended the mandate of
the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) until 10 October
2010, and requested me to report on its implementation semi-annually and not later
than 45 days prior to its expiration. The present report covers major developments
since my report of 1 September 2009 (S/2009/439) until 15 April 2010, with a focus
on the period since the devastating earthquake of 12 January 2010. The report
describes activities undertaken by the Mission in line with its mandate under
Security Council resolutions 1542 (2004), 1608 (2005), 1702 (2006), 1743 (2007),
1780 (2007), 1840 (2008), 1892 (2009) and 1908 (2010), and provides
recommendations on the future role of the Mission in Haiti.
II. Impact of the 12 January earthquake
2.
On 12 January 2010, Haiti was hit by a 7.0 magnitude earthquake, particularly
affecting the capital, Port-au-Prince; Petit Goâve, Grand Goâve and Léogâne (West
Department); the town of Jacmel (South-East Department); and the town of
Miragoâne (Nippes Department). According to the Government of Haiti, as a result
of the quake, 222,570 people were killed, many thousands were injured or
permanently disabled, and 1.5 million were left homeless. On 16 March, the United
Nations and partners launched a displacement tracking matrix that identified 460
settlement sites with a total population of 1.17 million internally displaced persons
in the Port-au-Prince area alone. Hundreds of thousands more fled the capital for the
rural areas and provincial capitals, in particular Gonaïves, Saint-Marc, Cap Haïtien,
Hinche and Les Cayes, placing great stress on local host families and communities.
3.
The capacity of the Haitian State was seriously affected. Two senators were
killed, and many senior political leaders were injured. The elections originally
scheduled for February 2010 were postponed, creating a climate of political
uncertainty. According to the Government of Haiti, up to one third of the country’s
60,000 civil servants perished. Many government buildings were destroyed or badly
damaged, notably the National Palace, the Supreme Court, the Palais de Justice, the
Parliament, the major courts and police facilities, and all but one Ministry. The
Haitian National Police was hard hit, with 77 officers killed and hundreds injured or
10-31957 (E) 230410
*1031957*
S/2010/200
unaccounted for. Half of the total 8,535 prisoners in Haiti escaped in the aftermath
of the quake, including several hundred who were being held on charges related to
gang activities.
4.
The United Nations itself was also a victim. The Hotel Christopher, the
headquarters of MINUSTAH collapsed, and nearby United Nations offices and other
facilities were severely affected. A total of 101 United Nations staff lost their lives,
including my Special Representative, Hédi Annabi, my Deputy Special
Representative, Luiz Carlos da Costa, the Acting Police Commissioner, Douglas
Coates, the Director of Political Affairs, Gerard Le Chevallier, the Head of the
Elections Unit, Marc Plum, and military, police and civilian staff. Many more were
injured, and others have been unable to return to work. Those who survived and
remained in the Mission have witnessed scenes of unimaginable devastation and
suffering. They are there to serve and, like the Haitian population, they are still
grieving for lost friends and colleagues.
III. United Nations and international community response
Emergency response
5.
Within hours of the earthquake, emergency relief operations were launched by
the United Nations and a number of Member States. Specialized military and
civilian units undertook search-and-rescue operations, established field hospitals
and provided immediate support to life-saving assistance efforts and restoring key
infrastructure. MINUSTAH, despite its own losses, acted as a crucial first responder,
opening the major arterial road from the Port-au-Prince airport to the town centre,
re-establishing communications and opening its medical facilities to victims. The
United States of America and Canada both began to deploy disaster assistance
troops to the most affected areas within 72 hours of the earthquake and built up to a
presence of 18,500 and 2,000 troops, respectively, by the end of January.
6.
On 13 January, the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
deployed a disaster assessment and coordination team to identify priority needs. The
team established an on-site operations coordination centre to assist the Government
of Haiti and to help coordinate logistical support for the international search-andrescue effort. Simultaneously, the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian
Affairs and the Inter-Agency Standing Committee expanded the existing
humanitarian cluster system and identified lead agencies for thematic areas.
7.
On 14 January, I sent the Assistant Secretary-General for the Office of
Operations in the Department of Peacekeeping Operations, Edmond Mulet, to Haiti
as my Acting Special Representative. The Assistant Secretary-General for the
Department of Field Support, Anthony Banbury, subsequently deployed to Haiti as
Acting Principal Deputy Special Representative. A small team from Headquarters
also deployed to MINUSTAH to support emergency functions and the MINUSTAH
staff who had remained in Port-au-Prince. On 24 January, MINUSTAH and the
Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs established a joint operations
and tasking centre, with military liaison officers from the United States Joint Task
Force-Haiti, the Canadian Task Force, the European Union Situation Centre and the
Caribbean Community, to facilitate coordination with international forces and to
provide a central hub for tactical planning.
2
10-31957
S/2010/200
8.
In the days after the earthquake, hundreds of bilateral aid agencies,
non-governmental organizations and individuals sent emergency assistance to Haiti.
Calls for financial assistance received an overwhelming response. The Central
Emergency Response Fund has so far allocated a total of $36 million towards the
Haiti response, as well as another $2 million for humanitarian operations in the
Dominican Republic. The Emergency Relief Response Fund for Haiti, supported by
the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, received $83 million, of
which $70 million has already been programmed. A revised Flash Appeal for 2010
has so far received $747 million out of a total of $1.4 billion being requested. In the
light of the vast needs in Haiti and the many actors involved, I asked the United
Nations Special Envoy for Haiti, former President of the United States of America,
William J. Clinton, to take on an expanded role in the relief and reconstruction
effort in order to help coordinate at the international level the work of, among
others, United Nations agencies, donors and private investors.
Humanitarian relief effort
9.
The scale of destruction caused by the earthquake created tremendous
difficulties for the initial relief effort. Electrical and communication systems were
destroyed, the main port was closed, and roads in Port-au-Prince were blocked by
rubble. With the assistance of the United States Joint Task Force-Haiti, Port-auPrince airport was reopened on 13 January. Initially, air traffic congestion and
prioritization of flights posed challenges, and many emergency supplies were
brought by land through the Dominican Republic where the Government had put in
place special measures to facilitate the transit of humanitarian assistance.
Humanitarian access improved quickly, with the assistance of the United States, to
enable the reopening of the seaport on 22 January.
10. Humanitarian responders have worked tirelessly to meet critical needs, paying
particular attention to the needs of the most vulnerable, including children, women,
the elderly and persons with disabilities. Significant progress has been made,
although much remains to be done. The World Food Programme (WFP) and its
partners provided 3.5 million people throughout the country with food assistance,
with MINUSTAH and bilateral partners providing security. General food
distributions are now winding down, with the focus shifting to longer-term food
security and investments in human capital. Programmes will include: support to
local markets; local procurement; and cash-for-work and food-for-work programmes
to support economic activity and agricultural rehabilitation. To ensure access to food
for the most vulnerable, WFP is providing meals for school-age children, nutrition
programmes for pregnant and nursing mothers and their children, and supporting
institutions and hospitals. It is also working with the Haitian authorities to
pre-position emergency supplies for the rainy and hurricane seasons.
11. Providing emergency shelter is now the top priority for the humanitarian
effort. The Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs has reported that as
of 6 April, approximately 90 per cent of those in need had received emergency
materials — 376,000 tarpaulins and over 45,000 family-size tents have been
distributed along with basic kitchen and hygiene equipment, ropes, blankets and
mosquito nets. With the rainy season approaching, a key priority for the
Government of Haiti and the humanitarian community is supporting the relocation
of internally displaced persons away from flood-prone areas. For those people who
are in at-risk sites and who cannot return to their home areas or stay with hosts, the
10-31957
3
S/2010/200
Government of Haiti has assigned 7,450 hectares of land north of Port-au-Prince for
temporary relocations and has identified five new sites around Port-au-Prince to be
developed for settlements. The United Nations and its partners are supporting site
preparation, developing assistance packages and working with local communities to
help the population understand their options. Emergency relocations from at-risk
sites began on 10 April and will continue until the end of the month.
12. Water, sanitation and hygiene remain serious concerns, particularly in the
spontaneous settlement sites. Since the beginning of the crisis, United Nations
agencies and non-governmental organizations have distributed over 4 million litres
of drinking water daily across more than 200 sites and 450 kiosks. Some 5,347
latrines have been installed in the earthquake-affected areas so far; the humanitarian
community hopes to add an additional 32,000 latrines before the end of June.
13. In the health sector, over 396 national and international organizations are
working to provide services to the public. With over 200 staff of Haiti’s Ministry of
Health killed, the World Health Organization and Pan-American Health
Organization Office in Haiti deployed 60 international personnel to assist the
Government of Haiti in managing public health risks, including coordinating the
provision of free medical services and vaccination of 300,000 adults and children.
United Nations actors and partners are also working to monitor and respond to
outbreaks of infectious disease.
14. With the aim of injecting cash into the economy and providing income to the
unemployed, the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and its
implementing partners launched an extensive cash-for-work programme shortly
after the earthquake. As of 1 April, 100,000 people had been employed in short-term
projects, including the cleaning of canals and removal of debris. The MINUSTAH
community labour-intensive watershed and canal rehabilitation projects were also
scaled up as part of its approach to reduce community violence.
15. In the coming months, the challenge will be to continue delivering
humanitarian relief in key sectors while also helping Haiti restore its own coping
mechanisms. For United Nations agencies and humanitarian partners, the next phase
of assistance will include decentralization towards regions hosting large numbers of
internally displaced persons. It will also include investment in agriculture, while
simultaneously ensuring access to food for the most vulnerable. Discussions with
the Government of Haiti are under way to support preparedness for the imminent
rainy and hurricane seasons, including setting up a harmonized contingency plan.
Reconstruction planning
16. On 18 February, Prime Minister Jean-Max Bellerive officially launched a postdisaster needs assessment to assess damage and losses arising from the earthquake
and to estimate reconstruction needs. Led by the Government of Haiti and supported
by the United Nations, the Inter-American Development Bank, the World Bank and
the European Union, the needs assessment also included consultations with
Parliament, civil society, the Haitian diaspora, the private sector and the people of
Haiti. Drawing on its results, the Government of Haiti developed an Action Plan for
the Reconstruction and the Development of Haiti, based on the need to “build back
better” through deconcentration, economic stimulation, social reform and
strengthening institutions. This Action Plan, an outline of which was presented at an
international preparatory conference in Santo Domingo on 17 March, estimates
4
10-31957
S/2010/200
Haiti’s needs at $3.9 billion for the next 18 months, with long-term reconstruction
requiring some $11.5 billion.
17. On 31 March, the Government’s Action Plan was presented to international
donors at the United Nations in New York. In a powerful show of support, donors
pledged more than $9 billion, of which $5 billion was pledged for the period 20102011. Many participants also spoke about the need for budget support to the
Government of Haiti to help finance critical expenses, such as public sector salaries
and the operation of schools and hospitals. The Government of Haiti indicated that it
would initially manage funds through an Interim Haitian Reconstruction
Commission, jointly chaired by Prime Minister Bellerive and President Clinton,
pending the establishment of a Haitian development authority and a Haiti
reconstruction fund, for which the World Bank will act as fiscal agent.
Implementation will be guided by the principles adopted at the Ministerial
Preparatory Conference on Haiti, which was held on 25 January 2010 in Montreal,
Canada. The chairs and co-chairs of the New York conference agreed to meet at
least twice a year with the international financial institutions and the United Nations
to monitor implementation of the Haitian plan and of donors’ pledges.
IV. Political and security update
Political situation
18. The earthquake interrupted a period of relatively smooth progress towards
legislative, presidential and municipal elections, previously scheduled to be held in
2010. On 14 September 2009, both legislative Chambers of Haiti had approved a
proposition in favour of constitutional amendments that, if ratified, would simplify
the electoral calendar and improve the investment climate, including by providing
for dual citizenship for the diaspora. Prime Minister Bellerive was sworn in on
12 November 2009, replacing former incumbent Michèle Pierre-Louis after a vote
of censure against her government. In late November, 69 political parties and
alliances had registered with the Conseil Electoral Provisoire, in anticipation of the
February 2010 elections. Of these, the Conseil Electoral Provisoire approved 53,
excluding, among others, Fanmi Lavalas, Eskamp, Konba and Union. Two new
parties had emerged: Inité (Unity), President René Préval’s platform, and
Alternative Patriotique pour le Progrès (Patriotic Alternative for Progress), a
coalition that includes the Fusion des Sociaux-Démocrates, the Organisation du
Peuple en Lutte and Konfederasyon Inité Democratik. This coalition is now
considered the principal opposition party.
19. On 27 January, President Préval announced the postponement of the legislative
elections that had been scheduled for February 2010. This triggered concern about
the constitutional status of the Government after 10 May 2010, when the mandates
of all Deputies and one third of Senators will expire. President Préval has repeatedly
made clear in public statements his commitment to holding municipal, legislative
and Presidential elections (in which he would be ineligible to stand) in time for the
constitutional transfer of power on 7 February 2011. On 22 March, President Préval
wrote to me requesting that the United Nations lead a feasibility mission to Haiti to
evaluate requirements for the holding of general elections and assess the options for
the timetable. Accordingly, the Department of Political Affairs will lead a mission to
10-31957
5
S/2010/200
Haiti jointly with UNDP and the Department of Peacekeeping Operations in the
second half of April.
20. Despite criticism by the opposition of the Government’s handling of the
earthquake response, wide consultations by MINUSTAH with political and civil
society actors indicate a broad acceptance of the need for political and social
stability to allow for reconstruction and to ensure a smooth democratic transfer of
power. However, questions remain about how to bridge the legislative gap between
May and the results of elections. Also in question is the future of the constitutional
reform process initiated on 14 September 2009. The Government continues to
engage stakeholders on various options. Consensus on the political way forward will
be an important basis for Haiti’s stability in the coming months. On 15 April, the
Senate adopted by a majority of 13 votes the law on the state of emergency, as
approved by the Chamber of Deputies on 5 April. The law extends the state of
emergency for a period of 18 months, and also creates the Interim Haiti
Reconstruction Commission, giving the executive branch significant powers to
implement the reconstruction plan presented at the 31 March donor conference.
Security situation
21. The security environment in Haiti remained generally calm. Before the
earthquake, demonstrations, which were related mainly to poor living conditions,
were generally peaceful and small in scale, except in Port-au-Prince, where protests
by medical students became violent on several occasions. Initial fears of large-scale
looting and violence in the aftermath of the earthquake did not materialize.
However, there were a number of incidents affecting the humanitarian effort. Since
January, eight kidnappings have been reported. There were also indications of some
increase in crime, including sexual and gender-based violence in camps for
internally displaced persons, though complete data is unavailable.
22. Significant new threats have arisen as a result of the earthquake, including
from former gang leaders who escaped from prisons, in some cases with uniforms
and weapons stolen from the Haitian National Police. Some of them have gone back
to their former neighbourhoods, leading to power struggles between old and new
gang leaders. With MINUSTAH assistance, the Haitian National Police recaptured
some 283 escapees by early April. Two known criminal leaders were reportedly
killed while resisting arrest. Although difficult to confirm, there are reports of an
increase in drug trafficking in Haiti as a result of the current weakness of the law
enforcement establishment.
23. Another new challenge is ensuring security in large settlements for internally
displaced persons, including prevention of gender-based violence, where
deteriorating living conditions, overcrowding and poor lighting are expected to
contribute to a rise in crime. Physical damage to rule of law institutions further
compounds this problem. There are also many broader challenges to the protection
of the displaced population, who are dispersed across more than 1,300 sites,
including obstacles to delivery of aid and the health risks associated with
overcrowding, inadequate water supplies and poor sanitation. Higher levels of
unemployment, loss of property and savings, and trauma arising from the events of
12 January also contribute to an environment of heightened vulnerability in Haiti.
6
10-31957
S/2010/200
V. Activities of the United Nations Stabilization Mission
in Haiti
24. Despite its vast losses on 12 January, MINUSTAH has made extraordinary
efforts to restore its capacity and has acted decisively to respond to post-earthquake
needs within its mandate and in line with the priorities of relief, security and
restoration of State capacity set out by the Secretary-General to the Security Council
on 19 January. The sections below focus on Mission activities since the earthquake.
Mission support
25. In the immediate aftermath of the earthquake, MINUSTAH provided vital
logistical and administrative support for rescue and relief operations. Strategic
deployment stocks were released from the United Nations Logistics Base at
Brindisi, Italy, to help restore Mission capacity as well as to support humanitarian
agencies. The MINUSTAH Logistics Base in Port-au-Prince, which suffered
relatively little damage, became the centre of operations for most United Nations
actors, and provided space and basic facilities to many non-United Nations
humanitarian responders. To accommodate the additional personnel arriving after
the earthquake, MINUSTAH relocated some staff to an adjacent camp that had been
previously prepared for incoming military forces. The establishment of an office in
Santo Domingo to provide services not requiring a physical presence in Haiti has
proven critical in enabling the Mission to move staff out of Port-au-Prince, where
living conditions remain extremely difficult, while allowing them to continue to
perform their functions. A land logistics corridor was also established between Portau-Prince and Santo Domingo, using freight-forwarding contractors and military
assets to facilitate the movement of critical supplies. Moreover, regular shuttle
flights were established to facilitate the movement of personnel between Santo
Domingo and Port-au-Prince.
26. A package of immediate measures was established to support MINUSTAH
personnel, including through staff counsellors, mandatory temporary relocation,
disbursement of cash advances and housing grants, and payment of funeral expenses
for concerned national staff. Special procurement delegations and extraordinary
measures were put in place to meet emerging challenges in a timely manner.
Mission capacity was maintained throughout the emergency period with the
temporary redeployment of over 300 volunteer staff from other peacekeeping
missions and United Nations Headquarters.
27. To address acute shortages of safe living accommodation, arrangements were
made to contract a ship for the purpose of housing MINUSTAH staff on a temporary
basis. Structural analysis of all MINUSTAH office buildings is ongoing, as are
assessments of private housing, which may allow staff to return to their homes.
Long-term arrangements have yet to be finalized. Owing to the potential for further
seismic activity, many areas of Port-au-Prince are considered at risk. In the long
term, the Mission is exploring the possibility of an integrated United Nations
compound in Port-au-Prince on Government-provided land, with buildings designed
to withstand earthquakes and hurricanes.
10-31957
7
S/2010/200
Military
28. The MINUSTAH military component provided immediate support in the
aftermath of the earthquake. MINUSTAH conducted search-and-rescue efforts at the
former Mission headquarters and the Montana Hotel, provided security support for
humanitarian operations, performed initial damage assessments and cleared critical
roads in the Port-au-Prince area. With the deployment of non-United Nations
security partners, an effective division of labour was established with forces from
the United States of America, Canada, Spain, Italy and France to provide disaster
relief and humanitarian assistance in the areas of Léogâne, Jacmel, Port-au-Prince
and surrounding areas, while MINUSTAH continued to provide area security
throughout Haiti.
29. Beginning in February, MINUSTAH was gradually reinforced with additional
troops in line with Security Council resolution 1908 (2010). A second infantry
battalion from Brazil, as well as engineering companies from Japan and the
Republic of Korea, began arriving in February, and military police from Guatemala
began arriving in April. As of 13 April 2010, the strength of the military component
stands at 120 staff officers and 8,186 contingent members, comprising 13 infantry
and 9 enabling units, including 4 engineering companies. Additional infantry troops
from Argentina and Peru are scheduled to arrive through mid-May, further
augmenting the Mission’s capacity to provide security and support humanitarian
assistance.
30. With this increased deployment, and with non-United Nations military partners
reducing their presence in Haiti since early March, the MINUSTAH military
component has assumed an even greater role in supporting the humanitarian effort,
including providing security escorts to mobile and static distribution sites for food
and other items, and by intensifying security patrols to ensure a secure and stable
environment. Engineering support has been extended to support the humanitarian
effort, including the preparation of two camps for internally displaced persons. The
integrated Joint Operations and Tasking Centre has provided a centralized entry
point for humanitarian partners to request assistance from MINUSTAH and
international military actors, and also to coordinate planning.
Police
31. Given the scale of losses of the Haitian National Police, MINUSTAH focused
its efforts in the emergency phase on supporting the operational capacity of the
Haitian National Police to maintain security and public order. Increased patrols and
security at key locations, including banks and warehouses, helped to create
confidence, deter looting and foster early re-establishment of economic activity. As
settlements for displaced persons expanded, the focus of police activity has shifted
to protection in those locations, especially for the most vulnerable. United Nations
police and the Haitian National Police have established a permanent joint presence
in the two largest camps for internally displaced persons in Port-au-Prince, located
at the Pétionville Club and Cité Soleil. Community policing bases staffed by female
officers of the Haitian National Police and United Nations police have been
established to encourage reporting of gender-based violence. Working in support of
the Haitian National Police, United Nations police are conducting patrols 24 hours a
day, 7 days a week.
8
10-31957
S/2010/200
32. As of 13 April, the strength of the police component stood at 828 United
Nations police and 1,350 formed police unit officers. The Mission is being gradually
strengthened with additional capacity in line with Security Council resolution 1908
(2010). New formed police units from Spain and France and a Special Weapons and
Tactics team, also from Spain, have arrived in the Mission. Additional United
Nations police and formed police units from Bangladesh, Italy and India are
expected in the coming weeks. Securing sufficient numbers of French-speaking and
female officers, as well as qualified officers in specific areas, remains a challenge.
Specialized areas of need include: training; civil engineering; architecture;
anti-narcotics trafficking; anti-kidnapping; organized crime; planning; forensics;
administration; procurement; logistics; mid-level management and regional
commanders; and special victims experts.
33. Efforts to build the capacity of the Haitian National Police are gradually being
restored, although at a reduced level compared with the pre-earthquake period.
Recruitment for the twenty-third and twenty-fourth promotions of Haitian National
Police officers is continuing, although with delays. Owing to capacity constraints,
classes for the incoming group of 1,016 recruits were halted. However, the joint
Haitian National Police/United Nations police team responsible for certification and
vetting restarted its work. Of 7,153 files under investigation in December, 3,503
were reviewed and recommendations presented to the Haitian authorities for
decision. With the United Nations copies of vetting files destroyed in the
earthquake, United Nations police are recreating files based on the Haitian National
Police archive. Meanwhile, the United Nations police supported the Haitian
National Police in developing a strategic framework for assistance, in line with its
reform plan, which was presented to donors on 31 March.
Community violence reduction
34. MINUSTAH continued its community violence reduction programme in
partnership with local and national authorities, focusing on 12 priority violenceaffected areas. In the immediate aftermath of the earthquake, the Mission helped
select food distribution sites, supported community coordination and launched six
new watershed management labour-intensive projects in the areas of Martissant and
Carrefour Feuilles in Port-au-Prince. An additional 15 watershed management and
39 canal clearing and rehabilitation projects employing 44,000 workers from the
slum areas have been prepared and are set to launch in May, pending approval by
United Nations legislative bodies. As part of an effort to ease tensions within camps
for internally displaced persons, an existing project to provide outdoor multimedia
screenings, including public service announcements, was reoriented to target four
camps of internally displaced persons in the Port-au-Prince area.
35. Projects ongoing before the earthquake were restarted or realigned to reflect
the new reality on the ground. During the reporting period, MINUSTAH completed
20 of 40 approved projects, including providing employment to 11,000 beneficiaries
and professional skills training for 350 youth; provision of medical and legal
support to 1,800 women victims of violence; and a pilot project providing business
skills training to women entrepreneurs in two violent neighbourhoods. The Mission
supported mobile clinics for approximately 1,500 street children, and began
activities to support minors who are in conflict with the law. With national and local
counterparts, MINUSTAH conducted social mobilization campaigns promoting
non-violence, tolerance and peace in all 12 priority areas.
10-31957
9
S/2010/200
Support to State institutions
36. MINUSTAH continued its support to the Ministry of Interior and State
institutions at the subnational level through its network of regional offices.
MINUSTAH officers provided technical advice and support to departmental and
commune-level disaster management committees in affected areas, including
identifying and managing settlements for the internally displaced. In response to the
severe destruction in Léogâne, the Mission established a new sub-office there and
worked with the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs and local
authorities to support relief and reconstruction efforts.
37. Within its capacity, MINUSTAH continued to provide support to both
Chambers of Parliament. Technical support focused on: legislation on gender
promotion; advocacy on the protection of children’s rights; prevention and
repression of corruption; law on habeas corpus; training in public relations and
media services; and parliamentary best practices. Drawing on technical assistance
provided by MINUSTAH before the earthquake, the Chamber of Deputies adopted,
among others, draft legislation on the customs code on 23 March.
38. In the area of border management, MINUSTAH refocused its priorities on
rehabilitation of the customs network and supported the Government’s postearthquake needs assessment.
Justice
39. Much of the Mission’s work in the area of justice was halted in the immediate
aftermath of the earthquake in the face of damage to the critical infrastructure of the
judiciary. MINUSTAH assisted in the recovery of documents and records and
worked closely with UNDP and the Ministry of Justice and Public Security to
finalize a joint recovery workplan for the period up to September 2011. Major
priorities are to recruit and train 30 new magistrates and to provide in-service
training to current prosecutors, justices of the peace and registrars.
40. At the end of January, the courts of first instance had resumed hearing criminal
cases in Port-au-Prince’s public prosecutors’ building, with 13 prosecutors out of
21 reporting for duty. MINUSTAH continued to work with the international
community to support emergency renovation of court locations and to assist the
Ministry of Justice in implementing four reform projects. Work also resumed on the
new draft of the criminal procedural code, while a draft law on prosecution of
corruption that was submitted to Parliament on 30 December 2009 was expected to
be discussed during the current extraordinary session.
Corrections
41. MINUSTAH identified three priorities for post-earthquake support to the
Direction de l’Administration Pénitentiaire: ensuring security at prisons still holding
inmates to prevent further escapes; ensuring the well-being of inmates by providing
food, water and medical services; and rebuilding the prison infrastructure to restore
detention capacity. MINUSTAH worked with donors to facilitate the restoration of
three damaged prisons, to augment secure detention capacity in compliance with
minimum international standards, and to support prison administration and planning.
MINUSTAH also undertook daily visits to prisons to ensure respect for inmates’
rights and international minimum standards.
10
10-31957
S/2010/200
Human rights
42. MINUSTAH adapted its pre-earthquake strategic priorities (strengthening
public policy, empowering civil society organizations and addressing impunity),
towards protection in relief efforts immediately after the earthquake. With the
support of additional staff from the Office of the United Nations High
Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) and the Office of the United Nations
High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), the Mission assumed its lead of the
humanitarian protection cluster and, in coordination with the Government of Haiti,
worked to coordinate an effective response by all actors. Priorities included:
protection of the earthquake-affected population, including those in spontaneous
camps; inclusion of human rights standards and principles in the relief efforts as
well as in policymaking for reconstruction; monitoring the human rights situation in
other affected areas, especially those hosting large numbers of internally displaced
persons; and ensuring participation in the protection efforts of the Government, the
national human rights institution (Office du Protecteur du Citoyen) and
non-governmental organizations. Medium- and long-term priorities include
enhancing the capacity of the Office du Protecteur du Citoyen and other national
entities, including non-governmental organizations, to promote and protect human
rights, and ensuring their active participation in international efforts to strengthen
the administration of justice and rule of law institutions in Haiti.
43. In March, MINUSTAH military and police led a joint security assessment
mission with the Haitian National Police, the United Nations Children’s Fund
(UNICEF) and the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) on protection of
internally displaced persons in camps, leading to a major surge in policing and other
efforts to ensure their protection. MINUSTAH also developed contingency plans for
protection in the event of additional emergencies and is developing small-scale
projects to reduce the vulnerability of internally displaced persons in host areas
outside the earthquake-affected zones.
Gender
44. Noting the loss of many prominent gender activists and senior cadres of the
Ministry in Charge of Women and Women’s Rights and the particular vulnerability
of displaced women and girls, including to trafficking and sexual exploitation, the
Mission provided technical support for the integration of gender concerns into postdisaster activities. In partnership with UNFPA, MINUSTAH also supported the
Haitian National Police in a pilot project establishing reception facilities for victims
of sexual violence in two police commissariats. Earlier in the reporting period,
MINUSTAH provided support to the Ministry to ensure a quota of at least 30 per
cent representation of women in public decision-making positions in the proposed
Constitutional amendments.
Child protection
45. MINUSTAH, in collaboration with UNICEF, continued to work to strengthen
the capacity of Government and other partners to address issues affecting children in
the context of greatly increased vulnerability following the earthquake. Key
priorities include: the prevention of sexual violence, in particular in sites for
internally displaced persons; the protection of separated and displaced children;
prevention of illegal adoptions and trafficking; and reduction of the high number of
10-31957
11
S/2010/200
non-registered orphanages. Children displaced, orphaned or separated from their
families are particularly vulnerable to trafficking, sexual exploitation and association
to criminality. Through the child protection sub-cluster, MINUSTAH is working with
UNICEF and other partners to improve security and protection in internally
displaced person sites and is also contributing to a campaign to promote awareness
of child trafficking. Institutions responsible for the protection of children urgently
require reinforcement. MINUSTAH continued to contribute to building the capacity
of the Haitian National Police for child protection and to provide technical assistance
for reform of adoption legislation as well as policy on detention of minors.
HIV/AIDS
46. MINUSTAH continued to conduct training activities within the Mission and
worked with the United Nations country team to integrate HIV/AIDS prevention
into the emergency response. Since the earthquake, MINUSTAH has trained 1,099
incoming military (39 females and 1,060 males), 592 United Nations police
(39 females and 553 males) and 92 civilians (29 females and 63 males), and offered
voluntary counselling and confidential testing to 235 United Nations police,
24 civilian and 80 military staff. Jointly with Family Health International,
MINUSTAH also trained 25 peer leaders, including Haitian National Police,
immigration and customs officials.
Public information
47. MINUSTAH rapidly resumed its communications and public information
efforts, including photography and video, after the earthquake. MINUSTAH FM
radio broadcasting resumed within five days, thanks to technical support from Radio
France. Cooperation with public information officers from all United Nations
agencies, funds and programmes enabled a coordinated response to thousands of
media enquiries and requests for technical support. The Mission and United Nations
partners planned and coordinated a large-scale information campaign to support the
relocation of internally displaced persons from dangerous temporary shelters to
safer accommodation before the rainy season.
Conduct and discipline
48. Following the earthquake, conduct and discipline training was temporarily
suspended. Despite decreased capacity, the Mission resumed a sensitization
campaign with non-governmental organizations and other actors and strengthened
coordination with United Nations agencies to ensure reporting of conduct and
discipline matters, with special attention to deterring sexual exploitation and abuse
of women and children. During the reporting period, two United Nations police
were repatriated for misconduct.
VI. Future role of MINUSTAH
49. In my consultations with the Security Council in recent weeks, I advised
Council Members that I would initiate a review of the role of MINUSTAH and
recommend any adjustments to the mandate or activities of the Mission that might
be required in the light of the post-earthquake situation. Accordingly, in March, my
Special Representative undertook a field-based planning process in close
12
10-31957
S/2010/200
cooperation with the United Nations country team and in consultation with the
Government of Haiti. Recommendations were endorsed by the United Nations Haiti
Integrated Strategic Planning Group in Port-au-Prince on 7 April.
50. The planning group concluded that the January earthquake had not destroyed
the gains towards stabilization made in the past few years but that it had damaged
them and created new obstacles. While Haiti’s population and institutions have
shown extraordinary resilience, the earthquake has generated vast new needs and
decimated the already weak capacity of the State to address them. However, the
devastation has also presented opportunities in the form of an outpouring of
international support and the Government’s vision for a transformed Haiti based on
decentralization, strengthened institutions and regional development.
51. The next 12 to 18 months will be a period of high risk, in which political,
security, protection and recovery objectives will need to be pursued simultaneously
to enable Haiti to keep to a critical path that, above all, preserves the political
legitimacy of the State and creates an enabling environment for recovery and
development. The role of the United Nations and its Member States in this period
should be to support Haiti’s Government and institutions in delivering on their
responsibilities, while respecting their authority and prerogatives.
52. On that basis, the United Nations must pursue an integrated approach in five
key areas that have been agreed among all responsible departments and agencies:
(a) fostering political stability, including through constitutional reform, elections
and democratic governance; (b) coordinating and enabling the post-earthquake relief
effort, while reducing the risk of future disaster, especially for the most vulnerable;
(c) maintaining a secure and stable environment, while working to strengthen the
rule of law, human rights and protection, and to support Haiti’s police, judicial and
corrections institutions; (d) supporting the Government in the implementation of its
vision for strengthened State capacity and decentralization; and (e) helping Haiti
begin building its human capital through promotion of a balanced social agenda.
53. Within this vision, MINUSTAH has a vital role to play. Whereas before the
earthquake, the Mission was entering a period of consolidation, a surge effort is now
needed for the next 18 months to two years, in which the Mission will help the
Government preserve the gains of stabilization to date and enable a smooth
transition to long-term reconstruction. Much of this surge can be achieved by
scaling up activities within the current mandate, while in a few areas the Mission
should provide greater technical, operational and logistical assistance to
Government and State institutions as recommended below. Across the five goals, an
integrated strategic framework will be developed to ensure complementarity
between the Mission’s activities and those of the United Nations country team.
A.
Political stability and elections
54. Haiti’s path to stability depends above all on adherence to a political and
electoral timetable that will allow for a smooth handover of power in February 2011.
In the coming year, my Special Representative will continue to devote his good
offices to supporting the political process. The Mission will step up its efforts to
engage all stakeholders, including civil society, with a view to enabling timely, free
and inclusive elections. Expansion of existing outreach efforts, with special regard
to women, is envisaged within the existing mandate.
10-31957
13
S/2010/200
55. A major focus of effort will be timely preparations for the 2010 presidential,
legislative and municipal elections. Those preparations will take place in a
particularly challenging environment, given the short constitutional time frame and
the need to renew the mandate of the Conseil Electoral Provisoire, rebuild damaged
voting centres, update the voter roll and take measures to provide for those who are
displaced and/or are without documentation. Subject to the results of the United
Nations electoral assessment requested by President Préval and, in consultation with
relevant partners, including the Organization of American States (OAS), it is
envisaged that MINUSTAH will provide expanded technical support and advice to
the Conseil Electoral Provisoire, including for logistics, security and planning, in
the context of an integrated approach with UNDP. MINUSTAH will also provide
support to the promotion of human rights required for the conduct of free and fair
elections. I recommend that MINUSTAH assume the lead role in coordinating
international electoral assistance in order to ensure its efficiency and avoid the
duplication of efforts.
B.
Support to humanitarian and recovery efforts
56. Meeting humanitarian needs and reducing vulnerability to new disasters are
vital tasks for Haiti and its international partners. As the relief effort continues to
ramp up and early recovery initiatives are developed, coordination will be critical,
including to ensure a smooth transition from relief to reconstruction. In this regard,
my Special Representative will continue to oversee the activities of the whole
United Nations system and, within means and capabilities, ensure the full support of
the MINUSTAH military, police and logistics components to humanitarian and
recovery efforts. Where requested, MINUSTAH will support humanitarian actors
with military and its own assets and will continue to facilitate joint planning and
coordination at the national and regional levels, in coordination with the Office for
the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs and the United Nations country team,
including facilitating the full engagement of national actors. I welcome the
cooperation of Member States to date with the coordination mechanisms established
by the Government, MINUSTAH, the United Nations country team and the
humanitarian community, and encourage continued engagement.
57. While the massive tasks of clearance of debris and reconstruction will
increasingly be assumed by civilian engineering contracts, which will also generate
local jobs, the scale and urgency of tasks will mean a continued demand for military
support. Where required, MINUSTAH military engineers will play a critical
enabling role by clearing debris, improving drainage, preparing alternative sites for
at-risk settlements and ensuring that access routes remain open throughout the
hurricane season. To respond to this need, MINUSTAH will reconfigure the military
component within the existing troop ceiling to provide additional military engineers
on a surge basis.
C.
Security, human rights and the rule of law
58. The lead role in ensuring public order lies with the Haitian National Police,
which responded strongly to the earthquake despite the very significant damage
suffered to its own infrastructure and loss of personnel. However, the postearthquake situation poses vast new challenges, particularly in ensuring protection
14
10-31957
S/2010/200
of the displaced population in special camps and elsewhere, especially the most
vulnerable. The Haitian National Police will need more assistance to face this and
other challenges, such as a potential resurgence of gang violence triggered by
escaped detainees.
59. Noting that the additional core tasks are in the area of policing, no change is
requested in the current strength of the military component. The force authorized by
the Security Council in its resolution 1908 (2010) is deemed sufficient to ensure a
secure environment, including through assistance to border monitoring, and support
to police where required. Within the existing force levels, MINUSTAH will continue
to reduce its total number of armoured personnel carriers by up to one quarter, as
described in my last report, and to replace them with lighter capabilities based on
the needs in Haiti.
60. I recommend that the Security Council authorize an expansion of the
MINUSTAH police component to help the Haitian National Police fulfil two
overriding priorities: (a) establish a sustainable and visible police presence,
including to protect the population in camps for internally displaced persons and to
maintain a conducive environment for free and fair elections; and (b) maintain
capable special Haitian National Police units to detain dangerous escapees and
tackle the risk of renewed gang violence. Additional capacity is required to allow
MINUSTAH police to develop an enhanced programme of co-location and joint
operations with the Haitian National Police, including a permanent presence at the
seven largest internally displaced person camps, of which the largest houses over
50,000 people, and to enable co-location of United Nations police with Haitian
National Police officers at departmental, town and district level, with appropriate
formed police unit support. This approach will involve increased logistical support
to the Haitian National Police, including establishment of temporary police
infrastructure in priority internally displaced person camps. The police approach
will be further supported by joint activities with MINUSTAH civilian units and
UNDP to bolster community security.
61. To this end, I recommend an increase of 680 police personnel, representing 200
United Nations police and three self-sustaining formed police units, in addition to the
force levels authorized by the Security Council in its resolution 1908 (2010). Based
on the Mission’s current absorption capacity, the entire force currently authorized
could be deployed by the end of September, with the additional 680 deployed before
the end of the year, in time for the envisaged elections. I intend to review the
effectiveness of MINUSTAH operational support to the Haitian National Police in
the coming months.
62. The posture of the MINUSTAH police component will form part of the
Mission’s integrated approach to the protection of civilians. Recognizing the urgent
protection situation, the Mission will scale up its protection and human rights
monitoring and advocacy, in particular to address sexual and gender-based violence,
and other civil, political and economic, social and cultural rights concerns, in
coordination with humanitarian actors. This effort will be pursued in parallel with
efforts to ensure the adequate inclusion of human rights within public policy in the
context of the reconstruction process and to fulfil the additional responsibilities
assigned to OHCHR by Human Rights Council resolution S/13.
63. With regard to the development of the rule of law, it is proposed that
MINUSTAH pursue a two-track approach to surge support for the Haitian National
10-31957
15
S/2010/200
Police, the Ministry of Justice and Public Security, and major judicial and
correctional institutions. This would involve:
(a) Provision of limited direct logistical support to enable the
aforementioned institutions to continue operations and provide basic services. This
may require putting MINUSTAH assets at the disposal of the Government, including
accommodation, vehicles and office equipment, which would remain under the
direct control and management of MINUSTAH; or, exceptionally, the loan of
MINUSTAH-owned assets to the Government of Haiti. Such support would be
coordinated with United Nations and international partners and phased out as donor
assistance materializes into new infrastructure and assets;
(b) Increased provision of technical expertise to Haitian officials, to support
the capacity for service delivery by police, courts and prisons, and to improve
governance and oversight capacities. This assistance, which is detailed below, could
last for up to two years and would require MINUSTAH to deploy United Nations
staff, as well as seconded experts, in ministries, police commissariats, judicial and
correctional institutions, on the basis of requests from the Government of Haiti.
64. This approach will be taken forward in the framework of the joint programme
currently under development with UNDP and the Ministry of Justice and Public
Security, in order to maximize impact of the United Nations assistance in police,
justice, corrections and violence reduction. In addition, MINUSTAH stands ready to
support the Government of Haiti in undertaking any possible long-term security
sector planning and review, should it decide to do so.
65. In the area of police reform, United Nations experts would continue to assist
the Government in vetting, training and mentoring police personnel, and would
provide technical expertise to the General Directorate and Inspector-General of the
Haitian National Police to enhance their capacity in oversight and management.
Progress in the development of the Haitian National Police, based on the 2006-2011
Haitian National Police Reform Plan, will also require strong Government
commitment. In this regard, adoption of a Government strategy to ensure that
Haitian National Police officers comply with standards and regulations would be an
important step. The Supplemental Agreement between the United Nations and the
Government of Haiti that was signed on 22 February 2006 will also require review.
66. In the area of justice, MINUSTAH experts, acting as advisers to Haitian
judicial actors and in partnership with UNDP, would help sustain essential judicial
operations and assist in timely processing of the heavy post-earthquake caseload,
including addressing cases arising from redetention of prison escapees, disputes
over missing persons, inheritance, land and property. In coordination with United
Nations partners, MINUSTAH would step up its technical assistance in support of
legislative action to reduce pretrial detention and tackle corruption and illegal
trafficking. The role of these MINUSTAH advisers would be to provide advice and
recommendations when requested; decision-making authority in all cases would
ultimately rest with the responsible Haitian official. In the meantime, MINUSTAH
would continue deployment of seconded corrections officers, as currently mandated,
to advise, train and mentor Haitian corrections officials, with a focus on improving
security and basic conditions in prisons, and monitoring progress in compliance
with human rights and international standards.
16
10-31957
S/2010/200
67. Both justice and corrections seconded personnel would initially be
accommodated within the 100 slots already earmarked for corrections experts,
within the total police strength authorized by the Security Council in its resolution
1908 (2010). The Mission will keep total requirements under review, in close
consultation with the Government of Haiti. All these activities will be
complemented by the continuation of the Mission’s existing community violence
reduction programme. To scale up its activities in cooperation with national
partners, specifically the communities and local authorities, as well as international
partners, in particular UNDP and the International Organization for Migration,
MINUSTAH has sought an additional $11 million to support earthquake-affected
communities at risk of violence, in addition to the amount of $3 million approved
for community violence reduction programmes for the 2009/10 period.
68. In support of the Government’s efforts to deter organized crime, MINUSTAH
will step up efforts to address cross-border drug and illegal trafficking, and continue
its support of border security activities by the Haitian National Police. In close
collaboration with Haitian authorities and interested Member States, MINUSTAH
would dedicate additional resources to counter-narcotics efforts, including
assistance to relevant Haitian National Police units. Noting that customs receipts are
a major source of Government revenue, MINUSTAH will offer technical expertise
and logistical assistance in the area of border management, in line with its existing
mandate. In coordination with the European Commission and other donors, the
Mission will provide customs experts to the Ministry of Economy and Finance and
advise on implementation of an integrated border management strategy.
69. Across the rule of law sector, including police, justice and corrections, my
Special Representative will play a leading role, in support of State institutions, to
coordinate the activities of the United Nations system and other international
partners. In this context, MINUSTAH will need some additional means to undertake
limited programmes in support to the Government of Haiti, to address pressing
needs in the rule of law area.
D.
State capacity and transformation
70. A critical determinant of stability in the year ahead will be the ability of the
Government of Haiti to ensure adequate delivery of services and opportunities to
communities outside Port-au-Prince, which would also help to deter a large-scale
return of internally displaced persons to the stricken capital. A positive result would
lay a strong foundation for the Government’s emerging policy of State
deconcentration, decentralization and regional development. Failure could lead to
instability and a renewed humanitarian and social crisis. Although other actors will
provide long-term capacity-building support, Haitian institutions in the front line
will need immediate support for the surge period to restore and strengthen their
operational capacity. In addition to the Mission’s existing partner institutions in the
Presidency, the Prime Minister’s Office and the Ministry of Interior, these “frontline” actors will include delegation offices in Haiti’s 10 departments, which will
need additional support to implement Government policies at the regional level.
71. It is therefore recommended that for these institutions, as for the rule of law
institutions referred to above, MINUSTAH should be mandated to provide expanded
assistance along the two tracks described in paragraph 63 above. This would involve:
10-31957
17
S/2010/200
(a) Limited direct logistical support, including for example access to
temporary office accommodation, equipment and facilities for Government officials,
to enable them to discharge their basic functions;
(b) Provision of additional technical expertise, which in this case would take
the form of MINUSTAH embedded advisers, which already exist in the Ministry of
the Interior and Territorial Collectivities and the Presidency, and would now be
offered to the 10 departmental delegations. Deployment of these advisers would be
on a demand-driven basis and in the context of an integrated approach with UNDP,
with a view to supporting immediate operations and enabling a smooth transition to
reconstruction and capacity-building.
72. To advance its vision for decentralization and create an enabling environment
for long-term capacity-building, it will be important for the Government to make
early progress on developing the legal and policy framework for decentralization,
which MINUSTAH stands ready to support in cooperation with other actors.
E.
Investment in human capital
73. Promoting equitable development and opportunities is a critical part of the
equation that will foster stability and enable the consolidation and eventual
drawdown of MINUSTAH. The lead in supporting the Government in this area lies
with the United Nations country team. The Mission should play an enabling role,
within its mandate and capabilities, to support the overall goals of the United
Nations to advance the development of a balanced social agenda in Haiti,
implementation of fundamental policies of social protection, especially education,
and progress on the Millennium Development Goals. Through its outreach and
public information efforts, the Mission will continue to engage students and young
people in support of activities by the Government, the United Nations country team
and other partners.
74. Finally, the surge period should see MINUSTAH make a renewed commitment
to mainstreaming social protection, human rights, HIV/AIDS and gender equality
across Mission activity. Existing MINUSTAH advisers will continue to ensure that a
rights-based approach in these areas informs the work of the Mission and, where
mandated, will fulfil specific monitoring and reporting responsibilities against clear
benchmarks and indicators, including in respect of child trafficking and progress
made in implementing Security Council resolutions 1325 (2000), 1820 (2008) and
1888 (2009).
75. It is foreseen that the above elements, taken together with the activities of the
United Nations country team, as well as the role to be played by the World Bank and
other regional and international actors, will support Haiti in weathering this
extraordinary period of transition. I would be grateful for the support of the Council
for the proposed approach, which should be kept under review as the needs and
priorities of Haiti evolve. In my subsequent report, I will provide an update on
progress, together with revised benchmarks and indicators.
18
10-31957
S/2010/200
VII. Financial aspects
76. By its resolution 63/294, the General Assembly appropriated the amount of
$611,751,200 for the maintenance of MINUSTAH for the period from 1 July 2009
to 30 June 2010. In the aftermath of the earthquake of 12 January 2010 in Haiti, the
resources approved for MINUSTAH have been utilized to meet the most immediate
and urgent requirements of the Mission and for the immediate recovery and
reconstruction projects in the country. On 26 March 2010, I submitted to the General
Assembly a request for commitment authority for the Mission (A/64/728) in the
amount of $120.6 million in order to supplement resources already approved by the
Assembly for the 2009/10 period and to address additional requirements arising
from the increase in the authorized strength of military and police personnel by
3,500 personnel approved by the Council in its resolution 1908 (2010). My request
is expected to be considered by the Assembly during the second part of its resumed
sixty-fourth session.
77. Pending the preparation of the proposed budget for MINUSTAH for the
2010/11 period, to be submitted to the General Assembly during the main part of its
sixty-fifth session, I am also submitting to the Assembly at the second part of its
resumed sixty-fourth session a commitment authority request in order to provide
resources for the maintenance of the Mission for the period from 1 July to
31 December 2010.
78. As at 28 February 2010, unpaid assessed contributions to the Special Account
for MINUSTAH amounted to $312.7 million. The total outstanding assessed
contributions for all peacekeeping operations as at that date amounted to $3,782.7
million.
79. As at 15 April 2010, amounts owed to troop and formed police contributors to
MINUSTAH totalled $28.1 million. Reimbursement of troop and contingent-owned
equipment costs have been made for the period up to 28 February 2010 and
30 September 2009, respectively, in accordance with the quarterly payment schedule.
VIII. Observations
80. Of all the reports I have provided to the Security Council, the present is
perhaps the most painful to convey. Once again, I wish to express my condolences
to all those in Haiti, the United Nations, and beyond, who suffered life-changing
injuries and loss as a result of the disaster of 12 January. We will remember the
fallen. Our best tribute to them is to continue their work, to transform Haiti and
build anew out of tragedy.
81. I thank and congratulate all those who, despite their shock and distress, have
worked to respond to the emergency. I recognize that the road ahead will be long,
and I wish to assure all Haitians of the commitment of the United Nations to
supporting their efforts. In this regard, on 31 March, I appointed as my Special
Representative Edmond Mulet, who has acted in that role from the very beginning
of the crisis and whom I know will continue to lead our efforts in Haiti with great
skill and dedication.
10-31957
19
S/2010/200
82. The Haitian people have reacted to the disaster with admirable dignity and
resilience. The Government of Haiti and political and civil society actors are also to
be commended for their constructive efforts to build consensus and ensure political
stability. Despite the scale of loss and suffering, Haiti has not fallen back to the
violence that was prevalent until 2007. Moreover, the Government has a vision of a
renewed State capable of delivering opportunity for all its people, including the
most vulnerable. Central to this vision is an ambitious plan to proceed with elections
that will allow for a Presidential transition in early 2011. This must be strongly
supported by the international community, as must constitutional arrangements to
allow the incoming Government to carry out its duties effectively in the best interest
of Haiti’s people.
83. I welcome the great generosity shown by the international community towards
Haiti, including the pledges made at the donors’ conference in New York on
31 March. The challenge will now be to translate these pledges into concrete
deliverables on the ground. I welcome the commitment of all those involved to
ensure that the reconstruction is Haitian-led, based on Haitian culture, history and
the aspiration of its people, with the active participation of all sectors of society. I
call on donors and the Government to maintain their commitment to a mutually
accountable and transparent process, with coordinated actions to avoid duplication
and wasted effort.
84. I am deeply concerned about the risks Haiti faces in the coming months, not
least with upcoming rainy and hurricane seasons. Relief and protection efforts must
continue to scale up, while the fragility of State institutions also leaves the country
vulnerable to the resurgence of gang activity, organized crime and drug trafficking
that could undermine the stabilization gains of recent years. Conditions in the camps
for internally displaced persons also create new vulnerabilities that must be
addressed.
85. I call on the Security Council to support the approach proposed in paragraphs
49 to 75 of this report for a surge effort by MINUSTAH to provide additional
technical, operational and logistical support that will support the Government of
Haiti in meeting its responsibilities, while respecting its authority and prerogatives.
I thank those Member States that have already contributed to strengthening the
Mission since 12 January, and ask for their continued support to enable MINUSTAH
to fulfil its role. I also thank the international community for its generous
contributions to humanitarian operations, and again appeal for urgently needed
funds, as the revised humanitarian appeal is currently only 50 per cent funded.
86. We should not underestimate the time required for Haiti to recover from the
earthquake. The statistics of the disaster and response outlined above tell only part
of the story. Hardly a Haitian family has been unaffected. Poor rural communities
are now host to those who fled the capital immediately after the quake. They
urgently require support to prevent a massive return to the capital, which would put
unsustainable pressure on the economy and services, not to mention housing.
87. As we support post-earthquake recovery, we must seek remedies to help Haiti
address historic social and economic problems; the deficit in education which holds
back progress on all fronts, the lack of effective rule of law and respect for the
human rights of all Haitians; and a housing deficit which, even before January, saw
hundreds of thousands of Haitians in improvised housing in shanties. It will also be
critical to ensure that the coming influx of international aid mitigates, and does not
20
10-31957
S/2010/200
exacerbate the unequal distribution of wealth and opportunity that has long fuelled
instability in Haiti. We must ensure that the new funds that have been made
available are targeted to assisting Haiti to build sustainable growth and stability,
tackle inequality and to meet the Millennium Development Goals. I know that my
Special Envoy will play a critical role in leading the overall international
coordination effort in this regard.
88. These will be extraordinary challenges in the coming months. I thank and
applaud the efforts of the whole United Nations team in Haiti, who have performed
admirably under the most difficult circumstances, and particularly my Special
Representative Edmond Mulet.
10-31957
21
S/2010/200
Annex I
United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti:
countries providing military staff and contingents
(as of 13 April 2010)
Staff officers
Country
Females
Males
Females
Males
Total
Argentina
9
37
514
560
Bolivia
3
16
189
208
Brazil
221
6
2 160
2 188
9
—
—
11
5
14
484
503
Canada
2
Chile
Ecuador
0
—
66
66
France
2
—
—
2
Guatemala
4
13
130
147
India
1
—
—
1
Japan
2
—
190
192
Jordan
8
—
592
600
Nepal
13
8
1 059
1 080
Paraguay
—
—
31
31
Peru
1
4
—
214
219
Philippines
1
1
6
149
157
Republic of Korea
1
—
4
235
240
11
—
948
959
7
—
—
8
13
42
1 079
1 134
114
146
8 040
8 306
Sri Lanka
United States of America
1
Uruguay
Total
1
22
Troops
6
Including the Force Commander.
10-31957
S/2010/200
Annex II
Composition and strength of the police component
of the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti
(as at 13 April 2010)
Number of United Nations police
Country
10-31957
Number of formed police units
Female
Male
Female
Male
Argentina
0
15
0
0
Bangladesh
0
6
0
0
Benin
1
18
0
0
Brazil
0
3
0
0
Burkina Faso
2
15
0
0
Burundi
0
0
0
0
Cameroon
1
10
0
0
Canada
14
70
0
0
Central African Republic
1
2
0
0
Chad
0
17
0
0
Chile
3
12
0
0
China
3
13
6
120
Colombia
0
34
0
0
Côte d’Ivoire
0
45
0
0
Croatia
0
2
0
0
Egypt
0
25
0
0
El Salvador
3
9
0
0
France
4
46
0
145
Grenada
0
1
0
0
Guinea
1
24
0
0
India
0
10
0
139
Italy
0
0
0
2
Jamaica
0
9
0
0
Jordan
0
28
0
286
Lithuania
0
0
0
0
Madagascar
2
10
0
0
Mali
1
41
0
0
Nepal
0
49
0
125
Niger
0
33
0
0
Nigeria
0
0
22
118
Pakistan
1
6
0
280
Philippines
2
17
0
0
Romania
5
15
0
0
Russian Federation
1
5
0
0
23
S/2010/200
Number of United Nations police
Country
Female
Male
Female
Rwanda
3
10
0
0
Senegal
0
23
0
83
Male
Serbia
1
4
0
0
Spain
5
30
0
23
Sri Lanka
0
14
0
0
Sweden
0
0
0
0
Thailand
0
0
0
0
Togo
0
6
0
0
Turkey
0
41
0
0
Uruguay
0
6
0
0
United States of America
6
42
0
0
Yemen
0
2
0
0
60
768
28
1 321
Total
Grand total
24
Number of formed police units
828
1 349
2 177
10-31957
10-31957
5
0
10
20
15
20
30
25 mi
40 km
Force Headquarters
Battalion boundary
International boundary
Departmental boundary
National capital
Departmental capital
Town, village
Main road
Secondary road
Airport
Abricots
SRI LANKA
SRI LANKA
URUGUAY
KOREA
LOG SRI LANKA
Deployment at Léogâne
10
0
HQ
April 2010
MINUSTAH
74o
OCEAN
Le Borgne
Port-Margot
Anse-à-Foleur
Jean-Rabel
Môle St.-Nicolas
Bassin-Bleu
NORD - OUEST
Port-de-Paix
St. Louis de Nord
Palmiste CHILE
ÎLE DE
LA TORTUE
Canal de la Tortue
73o
FPU NEPAL
CHILE
CHILE
CHILE
72o
NEPAL
URUGUAY 2
Criste
20o
URUGUAYMonte
URUGUAY
ÎLES CAYÉMITES
MP GUATEMALA
ARGENTINA
JAPAN
BRAZIL
CHILE & ECUADOR (-)
URUGUAY
Ouest
INDIA
FPU
Pointe
FPU NIGERIA
Canal de
Pointe-à-Raquette
Magasin
FPU PAKISTAN 2
ÎLE DE
LA GONÂVE
FPU JORDAN (SWAT)
FPU JORDAN 2
Cap Saint-Nicolas
BRAZIL 2
Canal de
Saint-Marc
Saint-Marc
ARGENTINA
NEPAL 1
Lac de
Péligre
Belladère
Lascahobas
Baptiste
NEPAL
Savenette
Terre Rouge
Cornillon
Thomazeau
Mirebalais
Saut-d'Eau
Arcahaie
Cabaret
JORDAN
La Chapelle
NEPAL 1
Cerca-la-Source
Maïssade
Hinche
Petite-RivièreC
E
N
T
RE
de-l'Artibonite
Thomassique
Verrettes
Thomonde
HAITI
19o
PERU
CapBaie de
Haïtien
Mancenille
Plaine
Quartier
FortLimbé
du Nord
Morin Caracol
NEPAL 2 Cap-à-Foux Bombardopolis
Liberté
Baie de Henne
Acul
Pilate
Gros-Morne
Morne Casse
Limonade
du Nord
Anse-Rouge
Terrier
Rouge
Plaisance
Baie
JORDAN
N O R D Milot
Terre-Neuve
de Grande
Ferrier Dajabón
Pointe
Sainte
Henne
Grande Rivière du Nord
Ouanaminthe
HQ PHILIPPINES
Golfe de la Gonâve
Dondon Suzanne Perches
Marmelade
NORD - EST
Bahon
BOLIVIA
Gonaïves Ennery
ARGENTINA
Vallières
SaintFPU PAKISTAN
Baie de
Ranquitte
A
R
T
I
B
O
N
I
T
E
Raphaël
la Tortue
PERU
Mont-Organisé
ARGENTINA
Saint Michel
Pointe de la Grande-Pierre
Pignon
FPU CHINA
La Victoire
de l'Attalaye
URUGUAY
Baie de
CHILE
NEPAL 1
URUGUAYGrand-Pierre
Cerca Carvajal
FPU JORDAN 1
Grande-Saline
Dessalines
ARGENTINA
BRAZIL
HQ MINUSTAH
Pointe
Jean-Rabel
The boundaries and names shown
on this map do not imply official
endorsement or acceptance by the
United Nations.
ATLANTIC
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC
Sa
um
UNITED NATIONS
g
Map No. 4224 Rev. 25
April 2010
Department of Field Support
Cartographic Section
Jérémie
Trou
la Gonâve
PRESQU'ÎLE
DES BARADÈRES
Croix des Étan
See Legend
Bonbon
SRI LANKA
Moron
Bouquets
Petit Trou
URUGUAY (-)
PERU
Dame-Marie
Roseaux
Carrefour PORT-AU-PRINCE
Gressier
Corail
de Nippes
Brache
Chambellan
SRI LANKA
re
Pestel
Ganthier
Malpasse
Killick
Source Chaude
Léogâne
Anse-à-Veau
Baradères
Pétion-Ville Fond Parisien
SRI LANKA
Jimani
Anse d'Hainault G R A N D E - A N S E
N I P P E S Petite Rivières
Kenscoff O U E S T
Miragoâne
de
Nippes
Petit-Goâve
Grand-Goâve
SRI LANKA (+)
Les Irois
Fonds-Verrettes
L'Asile
Trouin
Maniche
La Cahouane
Camp-Perrin
St. Louis
URUGUAY
Tiburon
Cavaillon
Les Anglais
La Vallée
Aquin
du Sud
BelleVieux Bourg
SUD - EST
Chardonnières
SUD
de Jacmel
Port-à-Piment
Anse Thiotte
d'Aquin
Marigot
Jacmel
Côteaux
PERU
URUGUAY
URUGUAY 1 (-)
Chantal
Bainet
Côtes-de-fer
Baie de CayesLes Cayes
Jacmel Jacmel
Roch-àSRI LANKA
Banane
Torbeck
GrandURUGUAY
Bateau
URUGUAY
St.-Jean
Gosier
Cap Raymond
URUGUAY
Port- du Sud
CARIBBEAN SEA
URUGUAY
FPU SENEGAL
Salut
o
o
ÎLE À VACHE
74
73
72o
Anse-à-Pitres
18o
18o
19
o
20
o
CUBA
S/2010/200
ât
25