Le rôle du charbon de bois dans les secours et le relèvement après l'ouragan Matthew
Resume — Note courte soutenant que la production de charbon de bois est un mode premier de réponse des ruraux haïtiens aux catastrophes, et que la planification des secours doit en tenir compte.
Description Complete
Cette note de trois pages de l'économiste agricole J.D. « Zach » Lea, datée d'octobre 2016 dans l'immédiat après-ouragan Matthew, soutient que la fabrication et la vente de charbon de bois constituent une composante première de la réponse des ruraux haïtiens aux catastrophes et autres chocs financiers : après la vente du bétail, le recours suivant est la coupe des arbres. Elle formule le propos dans le langage de l'évaluation, au regard du critère de pertinence entendu comme la conformité aux besoins des bénéficiaires et du pays. L'argument compte parce que le charbon est habituellement traité dans le corpus comme un problème environnemental à réprimer ; cette note le lit comme un mécanisme d'adaptation que la réponse aux catastrophes intensifiera faute d'alternatives.
Texte Integral du Document
Texte extrait du document original pour l'indexation.
Role of Charcoal in Hurricane Matthew Relief and Recovery
J.D. “Zach” Lea, Ph.D. Agricultural Economist
Relevance: “the extent to which…a development intervention [is] consistent with beneficiaries’
requirements, country needs…”
Making and selling charcoal is a primary component of rural Haitians’ response to disaster and
other financial shocks. Maybe first they sell livestock. After that they cut down that tree they
planted years ago as insurance against hard times. In this hurricane disaster, converting downed
trees into charcoal achieves two goals: produces quick cash and clears gardens for replanting.
The Haitian charcoal industry is the largest agricultural industry in Haiti, employing thousands of
workers in a value chain that connects Haitians at every socio-economic level. The charcoal industry
saves Haiti millions of dollars in foreign exchange that would be spent on non-renewable fuels,
based mostly on petroleum or natural gas. Haiti’s reliance on renewable fuel (charcoal and hydro) is
estimated at 50%-60%. That is, Haiti gets some 50%-60% of its fuel from renewable sources,
primarily, charcoal. That puts Haiti in a leading position as the world strives to become less
dependent on non-renewable fuels. For example, Germany has set the goal of moving to 25%
reliance on renewable fuels.
Efficiency: “how economically resources/inputs are converted to results”
The inputs (destroyed trees and other plant material) are available. Haitians know how to produce
and market charcoal via the traditional system. Efficiency of the traditional charcoal cooking
process is less than ideal; but, very practical. We can provide small charcoal-making retorts to
significantly improve the efficiency of converting wood to charcoal. See below.
Effectiveness: “the extent to which the development intervention’s objectives…are expected to be
achieved.”
The objectives are to provide market-based cash to hurricane victims and to clear hurricane debris
from affected areas. Assisting with the production and marketing of charcoal will effectively
achieve these objectives. In fact, project activities will simply enhance on-going, traditional disaster
relief activities.
Modern Charcoal Making Techniques
Techniques vary from very small scale to very large scale. Here I share a couple
Google https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tR6MslcJayk
Adam Downing, Agriculture and Natural Resources Extension Agent, demonstrates the process of
loading the kiln to make charcoal out of ailanthus and walnut timber. See following page…
Putting after-burner chimney on barrel of
burning wood soon to be charcoal
Two hours later, the charcoal is done.
Here’s a system from South Africa. It’s larger-scale than the one seen above.
Google https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cDkHLXddjhk
Here’s a British design on wheels.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fojgpct6dBA
Small-scale barrel in a barrel. Shows wood-gas burn-off
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J9W_PDhu3fY&list=PLKw_KSTb6QnvZBoE4HZqBY9Nvpht2tED9
Barrel in a barrel
Wood-gas burning off. This gas should be routed
into other uses: cooking stoves, bread ovens,
sugar kettles, alcohol distillers, electric
generators, etc.
Larger-Scale Retort from Mexico
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AD_8fbArUqk Larger-Scale Retort from Mexico